For The Footy Fans.

VVC-Geeza · 15th May 2024, 18:18

There is vote at the FA AGM on the 6th of June about the immediate abolition of VAR effective from the beginning of next season.

The premier league clubs are to vote and it needs a minimum of 14 clubs (two thirds) to vote for it to be abolished.Even then the FA have got to sanction it but it's highly likely they would.

Yes please it's it's ruining the game 🙏

trikey · 15th May 2024, 19:58

As a Coventry fan, my decision was made in the fa cup semi final..

Sent from my SM-G780G using Tapatalk

VVC-Geeza · 15th May 2024, 21:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by trikey

As a Coventry fan, my decision was made in the fa cup semi final..

Sent from my SM-G780G using Tapatalk

Utd were very fortunate that day but every chance they will get spanked in the final.

macafee2 · 16th May 2024, 07:58

mmmm should a team loose or win due to a wrong decision?
I saw a Youtube video of a goalkeeper receiving a Red card for handball out of his area. The goalie denied he had handballed the ball, when the ref reviewed VAR he rescinded the Red card as it was clear the ball had hit the keepers chest.

I agree after a gaol has been scored there can be a long wait for a VAR decision.

I sit on the fence, I like the free flow on non VAR but feel decisions should be right.

macafee2

VVC-Geeza · 16th May 2024, 10:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by macafee2

mmmm should a team loose or win due to a wrong decision?
I saw a Youtube video of a goalkeeper receiving a Red card for handball out of his area. The goalie denied he had handballed the ball, when the ref reviewed VAR he rescinded the Red card as it was clear the ball had hit the keepers chest.

I agree after a gaol has been scored there can be a long wait for a VAR decision.

I sit on the fence, I like the free flow on non VAR but feel decisions should be right.

macafee2

Human error has always been part of the game Ian and this stop start is totally spoiling the flow ow the game.There have been some fantastic goals disallowed for a big toe being deemed offside.Its become so mechanical and players now are almost scared to celebrate before a VAR check after every goal.According to talk sport this morning it has no chance of getting passed anyway.

xsport · 20th May 2024, 20:22

I think VAR should stay but with changes. Starting with the VAR panel of at least 3 or even 5 .each with a vote . There seems to be too much comradery between fellow current refs , in my opinion,to help each other out.The main grievence are the decisions about off side.Why cannot the lines be drawn with a second red line as well,so that it stays onside between those 2 lines. This then eradicates a lot of the time frame showing WHEN the ball was played from the boot. It gives a bigger tolerance that is surely needed. What is the point of calling off side for the width of a feeler gauge ? Other decisions for handball etc are welcome,but again the rules of interpretation of handball need looking at again. As far as disrupting the goal celebrations ,by waiting for VAR ,im afraid you will have to live with that.... if you want accurate and correct calls....

15th May 2024, 18:18	#1
VVC-Geeza This is my second home 2005 Connoisseur SE 1.8 Turbo,2004 45 1.8 Connoisseur and my beloved 1998 VVC Coupe. Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Derby. Posts: 8,790 Thanks: 2,022 Thanked 1,016 Times in 739 Posts	For The Footy Fans. There is vote at the FA AGM on the 6th of June about the immediate abolition of VAR effective from the beginning of next season. The premier league clubs are to vote and it needs a minimum of 14 clubs (two thirds) to vote for it to be abolished.Even then the FA have got to sanction it but it's highly likely they would. Yes please it's it's ruining the game 🙏 __________________

15th May 2024, 19:58	#2
trikey Premium Trader Rover 75 Join Date: Nov 2010 Location: Devon Posts: 33,807 Thanks: 8,837 Thanked 14,831 Times in 8,030 Posts	As a Coventry fan, my decision was made in the fa cup semi final.. Sent from my SM-G780G using Tapatalk __________________ Lest we forget..

16th May 2024, 07:58	#4
macafee2 This is my second home Rover 75 Saloon & Tourer Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Lincoln Posts: 14,954 Thanks: 1,630 Thanked 3,032 Times in 2,181 Posts	mmmm should a team loose or win due to a wrong decision? I saw a Youtube video of a goalkeeper receiving a Red card for handball out of his area. The goalie denied he had handballed the ball, when the ref reviewed VAR he rescinded the Red card as it was clear the ball had hit the keepers chest. I agree after a gaol has been scored there can be a long wait for a VAR decision. I sit on the fence, I like the free flow on non VAR but feel decisions should be right. macafee2

20th May 2024, 20:22	#6
xsport Posted a thing or two rover 75 club se Join Date: Apr 2011 Location: Leicester Posts: 1,718 Thanks: 358 Thanked 419 Times in 310 Posts	I think VAR should stay but with changes. Starting with the VAR panel of at least 3 or even 5 .each with a vote . There seems to be too much comradery between fellow current refs , in my opinion,to help each other out.The main grievence are the decisions about off side.Why cannot the lines be drawn with a second red line as well,so that it stays onside between those 2 lines. This then eradicates a lot of the time frame showing WHEN the ball was played from the boot. It gives a bigger tolerance that is surely needed. What is the point of calling off side for the width of a feeler gauge ? Other decisions for handball etc are welcome,but again the rules of interpretation of handball need looking at again. As far as disrupting the goal celebrations ,by waiting for VAR ,im afraid you will have to live with that.... if you want accurate and correct calls....